fundamental beliefs

In The Bias Against Homeschool Posted by Rachael Brownell (Redsy), the writer mentions that the bias against homeschooling relates ...
to a fundamental belief that children should be educated in a classroom, along with their peers, though clearly the days of the peaceful one-room schoolhouse, or effective public school are more or less long gone.

The phrase fundamental belief really caught my eye. I want to linger on it awhile.

The word fundamental in this case can be best defined as profound, or
being or involving basic facts or principles; "the fundamental laws of the universe"; "a fundamental incompatibility between them"; "these rudimentary truths"; "underlying principles"

So in other words the belief that children belong in a classroom instead of in the home is profound, ingrained, fundamental and rudimentary. This would mean that putting a child in the classroom is a natural and basic thing to do... that a child is as inclined to belong in a classroom is as natural as their urge to walk and talk.

But there's nothing natural about taking a child from a parent who can actually teach them and making learning difficult in a classroom situation full of distractions and frustrated teachers...is there?

To make things worse, if you look up the word fundamental belief, what you will find are references to fundamental religious beliefs.

Am I the only person sensing an oxymoron here?

So if it is a fundamental belief that children should be in classroom settings, shouldn't they also be exposed to fundamental beliefs?


Read more Notes From a Homeschooling Mom

Visit Free Home Ed. Homeschool For Free!

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

Hello,

My name is Tracy I'm a homeschooling mom of 4. I first seen you on youtube talking about that Crank dat song, I then went to your blog...lot of great information.

If you get a chance I would love for you to join some other homeschool moms at www.thehomeschoollounge.com
Blessings,
Tracy

Crimson Wife said...

Here in CA, 3 judges just ruled that the State gets to decide whether a family is homeschooling for "religious" (protected by the 1st Amendment) vs. "philosophical" beliefs (which are not). Talk about scary!

Ahermitt said...

yES, I read about it this morning... I am still at a lost for words about it... hope I can regain my composure and make some sense out of it soon!


http://www.hslda.org/hs/state/il/200802290.asp

Anonymous said...

Very true. It is a "fundamental" belief, but purely because it is the norm. I think the status quo tends to be self-perpetuating. People falsely believe that because something is the norm, it is inherently right. It is very difficult to challenge that assumption.

12 grade year of homeschooling, Finishing Strong

We are almost done with my college prep series. There will still be a video on completing the transcript.    Stay tuned... meanwhile, ...